Midwest American Economy on Life Support

KALAMAZOO, MI:  You have to be blind to believe the US economy is rebounding sharply from the corona virus lockdown. There is no “V” shaped recovery. At best it’s a U, with business activity mucking along the horizonal bottom of the “U.” 

During seven late July days traveling in the Midwest, I visited places where commerce was just barely ticking over. City centers in Cleveland, Detroit, Grand Rapids and Kalamazoo are largely empty, at best 20 to 30% of normal. 

Most restaurants and many retail outlets remain closed. if they have reopened there’s little business.  Parking is easy because many who are working do so from home. Local government offices are either closed or operating at minimal capacity. 

In Kalamazoo along what 60 years ago was the America’s first pedestrian shopping mall, nearly half of 64 downtown businesses say if current conditions persist they may have to close for good.  Ninety-five percent are losing money and 80% have received some form of government financial support

Three hours west in Chicago 4,400 businesses have closed in the past two months.

Not surprisingly, the hardest hit sectors are travel, hospitality and retail. Detroit’s usually crowded Metro Airport is struggling, recovering slowly from a 94% drop in traffic in April. Nationwide air travel is down 75%, a drop so severe that 3,000 passenger jets have been grounded. The air travel collapse creates ripples—to rental cars, restaurants, hotels, taxis and ride sharing. Number two car rental company Hertz is bankrupt and selling thousands of vehicles, putting downward pressure on used car prices. New car sales in June were down 30%, bad news for Detroit, still the nation’s automotive capital. 

The corona induced disruption extends to unexpected places. Hospitals aren’t getting the elective surgeries and visits they anticipated. Kalamazoo’s main hospital says revenue is down 50%, hundreds have been laid off. There have been pay cuts.   People are afraid to visit doctors’ offices. At Ann Arbor’s University of Michigan medical center that employs 26,000 the billing department staff of over 500 has been told to work from home indefinitely. 

Working from home has triggered huge gains for internet-related companies, but what about those dependent on commuting and offices? NPR’s listening audience has fallen sharply because people aren’t in their cars. West Michigan-based Steelcase and Herman Miller, major suppliers of office furniture, are suffering despite Miller’s CEO’s confidence that “the office is not going away.”

For small business the current downturn is a depression, certainly worse than the great recession of 2008/09.  The economy on a quarterly basis declined 10% from April to June.  

Data suggests it would have been worse without financial support from the Federal Reserve and emergency government spending. 

Economists at the University of Chicago and the JP Morgan Chase Institute say the bulk of the recent recovery in consumption comes from the unemployed spending their enhanced jobless benefits, while those employed are saving more and spending less.  Fed chief Jay Powell calls the corona disruption “the biggest shock in living memory.” The recession, he says, has wiped out the job gains of the past decade while the International Monetary Fund warns that “a premature withdrawal of fiscal support could derail the recovery.” 

To be sure there are winners from the health emergency. UPS and Amazon are thriving in the Midwest as they are all over the country. Big pharma Pfizer, a major employer in Kalamazoo, is ramping up its local facilities to mass produce corona vaccines that are already undergoing human trials.

Recently both Michigan and Ohio have done relatively well in dealing with the virus.  Each state  has about 80,000 cases but the death toll is greater in Michigan, 6,000 deaths compared to 3,100 in Ohio.  Nationwide at the end of July America registered over 150,000 deaths from the virus and 4.4 million cases.

I found people taking the virus seriously. They’re wearing masks, maintaining safe distances, and generally optimistic about the future.  Shanghai-born Charles Zhang, whose Kalamazoo investment firm is ranked among the best in the country, says west Michigan’s future is exceedingly bright,  that the region will not only recover quickly but thrive once a vaccine is available. # 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s