Americans: Anxious and Worried

In September the long-delayed Frank Gehry designed Dwight D. Eisenhower Memorial was dedicated in downtown Washington.  

Understated and situated in a park-like setting across from the Air and Space Museum, a visitor strolls among  panels depicting Ike’s childhood, war service and presidency. The most compelling statue is of General Eisenhower addressing troops setting out from Britain for the D-Day landing.  

Eisenhower Memorial, Washington, DC

Ike went on to become the 34th president of an America that was strong, rising and confident.  The country is very different today. 

I can’t remember a time when America was as divided as it is today.  Yes, there were deep divisions in the 1960s and early 70s over the war in Vietnam and civil rights. But today is worse. Here in the capital where 93% of voters went for Hillary Clinton four years ago, if you’re a Trump supporter you’ve learned to keep your mouth shut. To say anything suggesting support of Trump policies brings the risk of being thought stupid or ill-informed. 

Of course, things are different in the heartland.

Donald Trump won in 2016 because of public frustration with the way things were going.  Since the 2008 financial crisis living standards had stagnated, rustbelt cities and industries were hollowed out by foreign competition, the country was stuck in unwinnable wars in Afghanistan and the middleast. 

Trump was the great disrupter, finding fault with almost everything Barack Obama and the second George Bush had done. So great was the desire for change that voters were willing to overlook Trump’s obvious character flaws, coarse language and questionable financial dealings.

Donald Trump pulled back from the globalist policies that were embraced by Dwight Eisenhower.  He was a trade protectionist, lukewarm to NATO– demanding the Europeans pay more, tough on illegal immigration, sceptical on racial preferences, opposed to identity politics.

My own guess is that without the covid 19 pandemic and the president’s inept response he would be coasting to re-election.  Until March when the pandemic plunged the economy into recession, Trump’s signature tax cuts and deregulation had produced prosperity and a soaring stock market.  He was applauded for standing up to China, had built up the military, and brought troops home.

Trump was upended by the pandemic and it will be a miracle if he recovers. First, he denied there was a problem, then he reversed course, closing the economy. He refused to formulate a national strategy on masks and testing, and decentralized decision making to the states.  He pointedly refused to wear a mask and violated the maxim identified by historian James McPherson, that in times of crisis the most important function of a president is communication and inspiration.  

America in 2020, like most countries, is awash with problems.  A cancel culture has taken hold in universities threatening a long tradition of free speech.  History is under attack from those who argue previously revered figures should be demonized if they owned slaves or mistreated American Indians. The mainstream news media has abandoned objectivity and descended into advocacy. Identity politics and political correctness are rampant. 

If Dwight Eisenhower’s America was strong, rising and confident, today’s America is floundering, weighed down by  debt,  and unsure of who it is or its role in the world.  

John Mackey,  founder of the supermarket chain now owned by Amazon, says America’s problem is obesity. If Americans weren’t fat, with a high incidence of diabetes and heart disease,  there would have been far fewer deaths from the corona virus.  

There may be truth to the cliché that after seven decades of global dominance Americans have become tired, fat and lazy. The Chinese communist party seems convinced that America is a declining power that will soon be replaced by China.  Of course, that assertion is premature. America still the leader in technological innovation.  Its democracy and free market economy are strong and time tested. It would be a grave mistake to give up on America, no matter who wins the presidential election.  As Eisenhower’s contemporary, Winston Churchill, observed, “You can always count on Americans to do the right thing—after they have tried everything else.”  (ends)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s